Taylor Frankie Paul’s Ex Dakota Mortensen Sues Hulu and ‘Mormon Wives’ for Depicting Him as an ‘Abuser’ and Demands $300K in Damages

Dakota Mortensen is suing Hulu and the producers of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” for $300,000 over his portrayal on the reality series.

Mortensen, who dated cast member Taylor Frankie Paul, 30, on and off starting in 2022, filed the defamation suit Monday in Utah. The couple’s relationship has been featured since the show’s first season, with their final split coming last fall. The filing names Hulu and the production team as defendants, alleging they crafted a false narrative across Seasons 3 through 5 that painted him as both an “abuser” and a “serial adulterer.”

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

The lawsuit claims producers deliberately edited out his responses to on-camera allegations. During Season 3, which aired last November, rumors about an affair surfaced—but Mortensen’s denials never made it to air, according to the filing. His lawyers argued this wasn’t mere cutting for time but a calculated choice to mislead the audience.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

“The deletion of Mortensen’s answer while broadcasting the opposite implication was a deliberate editorial fabrication: it conveyed to viewers, as fact, an attitude and statement Mortensen did not hold and did not make,” the filing states.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

The legal team also highlighted physical evidence they say was buried. While filming Season 5, released this past September, producers allegedly captured footage of Paul striking Mortensen with a pizza box. That clip, the suit contends, was intentionally withheld from the final cut while the “abuser” label stuck to Mortensen.

“The knowingly false portrayal of Mortensen as the abuser in the relationship continued uninterrupted, while the only footage of physical aggression between the two, aggression by Paul against Mortensen, was intentionally withheld from viewers to promote a false narrative,” the document reads.

Another disputed claim involved Child Protective Services. Paul stated on camera during Season 5 that Mortensen had reported her to the agency; the filing flatly denies this ever happened.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

The damage, Mortensen’s side argues, has been severe and specific. The filing describes his “reputation and livelihood in the community where he lives and works” as “destroyed” by the cumulative effect of the editing choices.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

The backdrop to this legal fight is a relationship marked by public turmoil and law enforcement involvement. Paul was arrested in 2023 on domestic violence charges after an incident with Mortensen. She later pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and received three years of probation. In March of this year, leaked footage from the night of that arrest showed Paul throwing metal chairs during the dispute while her daughter Indy, now 8, was nearby. Indy is Paul’s child with her ex-husband, Tate Paul.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

More recently, both exes were subjects of a Draper City Police Department investigation in March regarding alleged domestic violence incidents from February. Police noted “allegations [were] made in both directions.” Paul claimed Mortensen slammed her head against a car dashboard. Mortensen, in turn, alleged Paul choked him and pushed him into a window. The mutual accusations led both to file for restraining orders, and Paul lost custody of their 2-year-old son, Ever, as a result.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

The lawsuit’s focus on editorial decisions rather than the underlying relationship chaos suggests Mortensen sees the production itself as the primary villain in his public downfall. By emphasizing what was allegedly filmed but cut—his denials, the pizza box incident—his legal team frames the case around deliberate narrative construction rather than incidental unfairness.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

No representatives for Hulu, Paul, or Mortensen responded to immediate requests for comment on the filing.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages

The reality series, which premiered in 2024, has built significant viewership partly on the volatility of Paul and Mortensen’s relationship. Whether that audience appetite for drama now exposes the network to liability will be tested as the case moves through Utah courts.

Taylor Frankie Paul’s ex Dakota Mortensen sues Hulu, ‘Mormon Wives’ for depicting him as an ‘abuser’, demands $300K in damages
Share this story