Legendary Surfer Kurt Van Dyke’s Girlfriend Arrested After He Was Brutally Killed in Home Invasion

The girlfriend of legendary surfer Kurt Van Dyke has been arrested nine months after his brutal killing, with Costa Rican authorities now alleging she helped orchestrate the deadly home invasion.

Van Dyke, 66, died in February at his residence in Hone Creek, Cahuita, where intruders tortured him for his banking PINs before leaving his body beneath a bed with knife wounds and signs of suffocation. Investigators with Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Agency (OIJ) initially treated the 31-year-old woman, identified only as Arroyo, as another victim after discovering her bound hand and foot at the scene.

That narrative collapsed as the months passed. Vladimir Muñoz, the OIJ’s acting deputy general director, told La Nación: “We were able to establish the involvement of a 31-year-old woman with the last name Arroyo, who had a close relationship with the victim.” Officers now believe Arroyo staged her own restraint and that the gang also faked the theft of her vehicle to throw investigators off her trail.

The breakthrough came Thursday when agents raided three homes and seized cellphones from Arroyo and a 34-year-old man named Gutiérrez, whom they also accuse of participating in the attack. The pair were arrested together, though two additional men who allegedly traveled with Gutiérrez to Van Dyke’s home that night remain unidentified and at large.

Girlfriend of legendary surfer Kurt Van Dyke arrested after he was brutally killed in home invasion

Peter, Van Dyke’s brother, spoke to The San Francisco Chronicle about the loss. “My brother was a very benevolent, giving person who would help just about anybody,” he said. “Kurt would never hurt anybody, and he was always there when you needed him. Everyone that he met knew this about him.”

The California native had earned the nickname “King” from local surfers for his willingness to take on some of Costa Rica’s most formidable breaks. He received his first surfboard at age seven in Santa Cruz and later built a life around the sport he loved, operating Hotel Puerto Viejo, a hostel catering to fellow surfers in the coastal community where he died.

Arroyo and Gutiérrez remain in custody as the OIJ continues working to identify and locate the two remaining suspects connected to the nighttime raid on Van Dyke’s home.

Share this story