A Sacramento mother and daughter were arrested Tuesday in the killing of a man whose severed head was discovered in a trash bag more than two years ago.
Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, faces killing charges in the death of her father, Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., 73, while her mother Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, was booked on accessory charges, the Placer County Sheriff’s Office said Wednesday. The mother-daughter duo allegedly worked together to dispose of the family patriarch’s remains.
The gruesome discovery came on Sept. 28, 2022, when someone found a human head in a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, a rural community in Placer County. The remains were so decomposed that investigators could not immediately identify the victim.
An autopsy was performed that year, and the skull was sent to California State University, Chico, where forensic experts developed a preliminary age and race profile. They also produced an artist’s rendering of the man’s face in hopes of generating leads.
The victim’s DNA was entered into CODIS, the national Combined DNA Index System database used to match crime scene evidence, but the search returned no matches. For nearly two years, the case remained cold.

A breakthrough came in January 2024, when investigators sent the DNA to Othram Labs for forensic genetic genealogy testing. The technique builds family trees from DNA profiles to locate relatives of unidentified individuals.
After Othram’s analysis pointed to possible distant relatives, the FBI joined the Placer County Sheriff’s Office in tracing the family tree. Federal agents interviewed distant relatives and collected DNA samples for comparison, which ultimately led investigators to identify the victim as Paul Fitzmaurice Jr.

A critical clue emerged during the investigation: Paul Fitzmaurice had never been reported missing. That explained why searches of missing persons databases had turned up empty for years despite the dramatic nature of the discovery.
Authorities said he had been living in Citrus Heights with his wife and daughter until his death. The family home became the focus of the investigation’s final phase.
On Tuesday, Placer County detectives served a search warrant at the Citrus Heights residence and arrested both women. Mary Fitzmaurice was booked into South Placer Jail on killing charges, while her mother Gwenn was arrested on accessory charges.
Paul Fitzmaurice Jr. Had been the family patriarch, living with the two women now accused in connection with his death. The case spans from the quiet suburban home in Citrus Heights to the remote Foresthill area where his remains were found.
The investigation showcased an increasingly common cold-case technique. Forensic genetic genealogy has gained prominence in recent years as a tool for identifying unknown remains and solving long-dormant cases, though it often requires months or years of painstaking family-tree reconstruction.
The Placer County Sheriff’s Office has not released additional details about the circumstances of Paul Fitzmaurice’s death or how his head ended up in the remote Todd Valley area.

