Why Colorado Springs Police Never Revealed the Mad Pooper’s Identity After Identifying Her Seven Years Ago

The Colorado Springs Police Department quietly identified the so-called “Mad Pooper” back in 2019, but her name was deliberately shielded from public view and has never been released.

Detective Britta Davis, then working in the major crimes unit, took the call herself on July 30, 2019, because both she and the caller spoke German. The woman, a European national, had phoned the department to turn herself in for a string of 2017 incidents that had made national headlines and spawned endless internet memes.

“I’m calling because unfortunately I was the Mad Pooper,” the woman said, according to a re-enacted call featured in TLC’s new two-part documentary “Mad Pooper,” She told Davis she felt “extremely sorry and embarrassed” about repeatedly defecating on neighbors’ lawns in a Colorado Springs community while visiting America for work.

Colorado Springs Police identified the Mad Pooper seven years ago – here’s why they never revealed her identity

The woman attributed her actions to what she described as a “nervous problem” that meant she “can’t control herself.” Davis pressed her on why she kept returning to the same location, but the caller offered no explanation beyond her shame. “I’m so ashamed that I did this,” she told the detective.

Davis documented the confession and passed it to her supervisor, yet she made a deliberate choice to keep the woman’s identity out of media reports. The statute of limitations on the misdemeanor offense had already expired, and the detective saw no public benefit to exposing someone who had voluntarily come forward to apologize.

“It was a misdemeanor case and the statue of limitation had run out,” Davis explained in the TLC documentary. “You had identified, you had called, you had apologized, I documented it, I provided it to my supervisor, but I was determined to not make a media report that I identified the Mad Pooper.”

The caller’s fear of online harassment factored heavily into Davis’s decision. The detective noted that the woman was specifically afraid the department would release her name, leaving her vulnerable to the kind of internet pile-on that the case had already generated in abundance.

Investigative journalist Sean Beedle, who spent years probing the case and appears in the TLC series, ultimately obtained the 2019 police reports and managed to unredact the woman’s name. He and producers tried to contact her directly for the documentary, but their outreach went unanswered.

Beedle said that he supports the choice to keep her identity private. “You do tend to feel little bit of empathy towards these people,” he said. “You kind of understand maybe why they do the things that they do and it gives you a little bit of sympathy.”

The balancing act between public curiosity and human decency is one Beedle knows well. “It can be difficult in that regard because on the one hand you’re you’re doing this public investigation for the public interest and trying to like identify someone who committed a crime all these years ago,” he continued. “But at the same time, they’re a human being with their own struggles. It’s just difficult kind of balancing those two aspects of the job.”

Colorado Springs Police identified the Mad Pooper seven years ago – here’s why they never revealed her identity

Beedle expressed doubt that naming the woman would serve any constructive purpose. “I’m sure most people can you know empathize with like doing something stupid or weird or problematic in their past that, you know, they regret now,” he said.

The original 2017 incidents unfolded in a Colorado Springs neighborhood where residents began finding human feces on their properties with disturbing regularity. The culprit appeared to be a female jogger who would relieve herself in broad daylight, sometimes carrying napkins with her. One family, the Budde family, went public with surveillance footage after catching the woman in the act multiple times near their home. The story exploded across national media, drawing comparisons to other “serial pooper” cases and inspiring a wave of crude humor that the woman herself would likely face again should her name surface.

Colorado Springs police fielded numerous prank calls from people falsely claiming to be the perpetrator at the height of the media frenzy. The genuine confession, when it finally came two years later, arrived without fanfare and was buried in department files until Beedle’s documentary investigation.

Beedle said his team corroborated key details to satisfy themselves they had found the right person. “We’re pretty sure. We did a lot of corroboration of supporting details. We found this person on various social media outlets, and we found some pictures to compare. I feel pretty confident that it’s case closed at this point,” he stated.

Colorado Springs Police identified the Mad Pooper seven years ago – here’s why they never revealed her identity

The TLC documentary “Mad Pooper” is currently streaming as a two-part special.

Share this story