Longtime Parade Santa Uses Hilarious Anniversary Fake-Out for Surprise Proposal

James O’Toole, 60, proposed to Keri Sommer, 51, at the New Rochelle Christmas parade on Saturday after using his 40th anniversary as Santa Claus as cover for the surprise.

The longtime parade Santa had played Kris Kringle in the suburban New York city since he was 20, making the milestone celebration the perfect smoke screen for a romantic ambush. Sommer was also marking her birthday that same day, though she had no idea a ring was coming.

“We’ve been talking about it and stuff like that, but you know she didn’t think I was going to do anything like that,” O’Toole said. “But I finally said ‘OK, gotta tie the knot one day.’ So I decided to do it on her birthday.”

O’Toole recruited Westchester County Rep. George Latimer to help sell the ruse. The Democrat’s office prepared an official proclamation honoring O’Toole’s four decades in the red suit, setting the stage for a public presentation at the end of the parade route.

Longtime parade Santa uses hilarious anniversary fake-out for surprise proposal

When Latimer moved to present the honor in front of family, friends, and the gathered crowd, O’Toole dropped to one knee beside his unsuspecting girlfriend.

“I went down on one knee with her up there with me, you know in front of the crowd, and then –boom! She was totally not expecting it at all,” he said.

Longtime parade Santa uses hilarious anniversary fake-out for surprise proposal

Sommer admitted she had been irritated with O’Toole earlier in the day because he “didn’t even do anything for my birthday.” That frustration evaporated the moment she realized what was actually happening.

“It was great; I couldn’t ask for anything better,” Sommer said.

“What a cool proposal, it’s awesome, everybody got in on film, everybody was there because I thought it was for James, so it was really nice,” she added.

The couple has been together for nearly 20 years. They had not discussed wedding plans before the proposal, but Sommer floated one festive possibility for the ceremony.

“You never know,” she joked. “We’ll have a float.”

Share this story