How Long Below Deck Alum João Franco Could Serve in Turkish Prison After Fatal Fistfight and Why He Has a Better Argument Than His Brother

João Franco and his brother Karlos could spend decades in a Turkish prison depending on how prosecutors choose to charge them over a fatal brawl that left a teenage store employee dead.

The “Below Deck Mediterranean” alum, 36, and his sibling are being held in prison after their arrest following the Nov. 7 fight outside a clothing store in Bodrum, a district in Turkey’s Muğla province, according to CCTV footage. The video shows Karlos approaching an employee, exchanging words and appearing to throw the first punch before João stepped in to separate them. The situation escalated rapidly as additional employees emerged from the shop and a chaotic scuffle broke out involving punches, kicks and at least one person lifting a stool to use as a weapon.

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

Todd Spodek, a New York federal criminal defense attorney with experience representing clients prosecuted in Turkey, outlined the three possible charges the Bodrum Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office could pursue. Intentional killing carries a life sentence. Intentional injury resulting in death brings 10 to 18 years depending on aggravated circumstances. Negligent homicide carries two to six years.

“The single most important question in this case is how Turkish prosecutors charge it because that decides almost everything about the sentence,” Spodek said.

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

“If they treat it as an intentional killing, the brothers are facing a potential life sentence. If it’s charged the way these bar-fight cases often are, as an assault that unintentionally resulted in death, the exposure drops to roughly a decade or more. If a court finds it was reckless rather than intentional, it drops further still.”

He added, “There’s also a middle option called ‘eventual intent,’ which means the person didn’t mean to kill but knew death could happen. It’s less than life [in prison] but still a long sentence.”

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

Spodek expressed skepticism about the most serious charge sticking against either brother. He said he’d be “surprised if prosecutors could prove intentional killing from one punch and a fall.”

The footage reveals João attempting to de-escalate at various points during the roughly minute-long confrontation. However, he eventually appeared to swing his fist, after which a teenage staffer fell to the ground and lay motionless. The 17-year-old reportedly struck his head on steps during the fall, was rushed to Muğla Training and Research Hospital in critical condition, and later died from his injuries.

“The video will matter more than anything either side says,” Spodek stressed.

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

The Francos, residents of Portugal, were taken to Bodrum Courthouse following their arrest and remain incarcerated. They reportedly told police they were attacked and fought back in self-defense, denying that either of them struck the deceased victim.

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

Self-defense arguments face significant hurdles under Turkish law, particularly for Karlos. “Self-defense exists in Turkey, as does a reduction for being provoked or for going too far while defending yourself. If the video shows João trying to break it up and only swinging once things got out of hand, he has a better argument than his brother,” Spodek explained.

“Karlos has a harder time if he started it. You can’t start a fight and then claim self-defense. Either way, the more punches you throw, the weaker the claim gets.”

Spodek noted that Turkish prosecutors can treat multiple participants in the same fight as acting together, potentially blurring individual responsibility regardless of who initiated the confrontation or landed the fatal blow. This legal approach could undermine any distinction between the brothers’ respective levels of culpability.

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

Intoxication, if present, offers no shield for the defendants. “Like here, choosing to drink is not a defense. It can actually hurt because it makes their version of events less believable,” Spodek said.

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

Turkey’s criminal justice system differs substantially from American proceedings in one crucial respect: no jury decides the brothers’ fate. Instead, Spodek explained, “a panel of judges hears the evidence” and renders a verdict.

Before any trial can commence, the Bodrum Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office must issue an indictment, which the Bodrum Court must then accept. The Francos remain in prison during this preliminary phase, with their ultimate sentence range spanning from a few years to life behind bars depending entirely on prosecutorial discretion.

How long ‘Below Deck’ alum João Franco could serve in Turkish prison for fatal fistfight — and why he has ‘better argument’ than his brother

The incident that led to the Francos’ imprisonment began as a seemingly routine evening outside a retail establishment in the popular Turkish resort town. What transpired in approximately 60 seconds of surveillance footage has now left one family mourning a teenager’s death and two brothers facing the prospect of extended incarceration far from their Portuguese home.

Share this story