Lindsay Clancy Will Face Trial Again for Murdering Her 3 Kids as Judge Sets New Date Saying ‘The Die Has Been Cast’

Lindsay Clancy will stand trial again for the deaths of her three children.

Judge William Sullivan set the retrial for March 29 during a hearing Monday in Plymouth, Massachusetts, after prosecutors from Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz’s office announced they would pursue murder charges a second time. Clancy, 36, of Duxbury, previously faced a five-week trial that ended with a deadlocked jury unable to reach a verdict.

Lindsay Clancy will face trial again for murdering her 3 kids — as judge picks new date: ‘The die has been cast’

Her defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, 75, revealed at the hearing that he would have considered a plea deal if prosecutors had guaranteed his client could remain institutionalized rather than imprisoned. Reddington also pressed Cruz’s office to reduce the charges to second-degree murder, which would allow a judge rather than a jury to decide the case.

“The die has been cast,” Reddington said at the hearing in Plymouth court.

The jury from the first trial later disclosed that they had nearly acquitted Clancy entirely, splitting 11 to 1 in favor of a not guilty by reason of insanity verdict. The sole holdout juror blocked the acquittal.

Reddington had asked jurors to find Clancy not criminally responsible for killing Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, on January 24, 2023. His central argument rested on claims that she suffered from extreme postpartum psychosis and hallucinated a voice commanding her to carry out the killings.

Lindsay Clancy will face trial again for murdering her 3 kids — as judge picks new date: ‘The die has been cast’

Court testimony established that Clancy’s mental health had deteriorated for four months preceding the deaths. She experienced insomnia, anxiety, depression, and thoughts of suicide and harming her children during that period. She regularly met with a psychiatrist, sought assistance from two perinatal clinics, called a suicide hotline twice, and checked herself into a mental health facility for nearly five days.

Prosecutors countered that Clancy remained lucid enough to deliberately plan and execute the killings, including sending her then-husband out on errands to prevent his intervention. They maintained she never exhibited psychosis and never reported hearing voices to her doctors, characterizing both claims as convenient tactics to evade responsibility.

Clancy allegedly fatally strangled all three children in the family’s Duxbury home.

Lindsay Clancy will face trial again for murdering her 3 kids — as judge picks new date: ‘The die has been cast’

The original trial featured competing narratives of a mother in psychiatric crisis versus a calculated killer masking intent behind mental health claims. The 11-1 jury split revealed how deeply the insanity defense resonated with most panelists, even as the single dissenting juror forced the mistrial.

Reddington continues to challenge whether Clancy killed her children at all, a shift from his previous strategy that accepted the killings but argued lack of criminal responsibility.

Clancy’s retrial is scheduled to begin March 29 in Plymouth.

Share this story