David Smith wants his ex-wife to die behind bars.
The 56-year-old father of two murdered boys said ahead of Thursday’s parole hearing that Susan Smith, 55, should remain “in prison until she dies” for drowning their sons Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, in 1994. The South Carolina mom has spent decades at Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood and now faces her second bid for freedom in less than a year.
“32 years hasn’t changed the heartache,” David Smith said in his interview with the outlet. He described the upcoming hearing before the parole board as another painful reopening of wounds that have never closed. The father has become a vocal opponent of his ex-wife’s release, returning to argue against her at a previous parole hearing in November 2024.

At that earlier hearing, David Smith made his position unmistakable. “She purposely meant to end their lives. I never have felt any remorse from her. She never expressed any to me,” he claimed. He has consistently rejected any framing of the deaths as accidental, insisting the killings were calculated and cruel.
Susan Smith offered a starkly different account when she addressed the same parole board in 2024. “I am a Christian and God is a big part of my life and I know he has forgiven me. … And I just ask that you show that same kind of mercy as well,” she said. She also acknowledged that what she did was “horrible,” though her expression of regret has done nothing to sway the children’s father.

The gulf between their positions traces back to the original investigation, when Susan Smith, then 23, fabricated a story that gripped the nation. She initially told police and media outlets that a Black man had carjacked her at a stoplight in Union, South Carolina, and driven off with her children still in the vehicle. For nine days, a nationwide search unfolded while she and David Smith made emotional televised pleas for the safe return of their sons.
David Smith learned the devastating truth through a television broadcast. “I didn’t know what was going on. I had believed her. I found out that she killed our children on live TV,” he recounted. The revelation came after investigators began pressing Susan Smith on inconsistencies in her account, leading her to confess that she had driven her car into John D. Long Lake with Michael and Alex trapped inside.
Prosecutors argued at trial that she carried out the murders to salvage an affair with a married man who had told her he did not want children. A jury convicted her and sentenced her to life in prison, a term that has now stretched across three decades.

Ahead of Thursday’s hearing, David Smith’s message to the parole board remained unwavering. “It’s been hard, hard,” he urged. “If I have a choice, I’d want her to stay in prison until she dies.” He has asked the board to weigh not just the passage of time but the permanent absence his family continues to endure.
Susan Smith’s first parole bid in November 2024 ended in denial, though the board’s reasoning was not publicly detailed. Her return to the board so quickly suggests she intends to keep pursuing release, setting up what could become repeated confrontations with the father of her victims.

David Smith said the murders still feel like “yesterday” to him, a sentiment that has fueled his repeated appearances before parole officials.

