Traitors stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites hint their post-show date sparked something more

Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites are playing it coy about their budding romance after confirming they went on a post-show date.

The “Traitors: New Blood” stars sat down with the outlet’s “Virtual Reali-Tea” podcast one day after the emotional season finale aired, trading flirtatious banter about their future together. Fites, 23, a marketing manager from the season, even playfully suggested they return to the Scottish castle for a proposal.

“Should we go back to the castle and you can propose in the castle?” she asked her co-star, who quickly agreed it would be “so sick” to get down on one knee in the Scotland abode.

Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date

While Fites maintained that the “Traitors” castle is only a good place to fall in love “if you want trust issues,” Vollbrechthausen, 26, took a more optimistic view of their unusual origin story. The business executive argued that surviving the cutthroat competition together built a foundation most couples never test.

“If you can get through a game of ‘Traitors,’ what can’t you get through?” he said during the interview.

Their path to romance was hardly straightforward inside the Scottish castle. Vollbrechthausen, a devout Faithful who openly worried his crush would cloud his judgment during the game, ultimately voted to banish Fites at the Fire of Truth ceremony despite his clear fondness for her. Fites, meanwhile, was a Traitor who had said at the time that she would not go out with him after filming wrapped.

Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date

She has since changed her tune entirely. In a recent interview, Vollbrechthausen opened up about the challenge of winning her over once cameras stopped rolling.

“If hunting Traitors was hard, convincing her to let me take her out, that was definitely … I think I’m prouder of that,” he told the outlet. “But yeah, we did. We finally got that date.”

Fites confirmed the meetup went “great,” though she kept things deliberately vague when pressed about whether a second date was already in the works.

“We’ll see,” she said of their future as a romantic pair.

Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date

The duo made it to the final five in the two-hour season finale before Traitor Shane Beatty emotionally turned on Fites, his fellow Traitor, and took home the whopping $246,300 prize pot solo. That dramatic conclusion aired just before the pair began their media tour addressing their off-screen connection.

Vollbrechthausen and Fites are not the first “Traitors” contestants to spark romance rumors after leaving the castle. “Real Housewives of Atlanta” star Phaedra Parks confirmed in September that she was dating her “Traitors US” Season 2 co-star Chris “CT” Tamburello, with a source later saying that “he makes her really happy” and that “they really do laugh together a lot and their relationship is really sweet.”

Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date

Season 4 winner Rob Rausch and runner-up Maura Higgins also faced an onslaught of dating rumors thanks to their flirtatious behavior in the Scottish abode, though their relationship ultimately remained platonic.

With “Traitors: New Blood” now fully available for streaming on Peacock, fans can turn their attention to Season 5 of “The Traitors,” which premieres Jan. 14, 2027. That season will feature celebrities including Craig Conover, Kristin Chenoweth, Emira D’Spain, Whitney Leavitt, Cynthia Bailey, and Cody Simpson.

Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date
Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date
Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date
Exclusive | ‘Traitors: New Blood’ stars Victor Vollbrechthausen and Katie Fites tease budding romance after confirming post-show date
Share this story