A new clip from HBO’s upcoming Harry Potter series has reignited fan complaints about its visual style after airing during Saturday’s Kids’ Choice Awards.
The footage from Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone shows Harry, Ron, and Hermione at the start-of-term feast following the Sorting Ceremony, with the Great Hall students chanting Dumbledore’s name. John Lithgow, 79, appears as the Hogwarts headmaster in the scene.
Dominic McLaughlin, the young actor cast as Harry Potter, asks Ron Weasley — played by Alastair Stout — whether Dumbledore is “a bit mad.” Stout’s Ron replies: “Yep, totally off his rocker.”

The clip‘s release brought immediate comparisons to the original film franchise, with viewers on X and other platforms focusing on the series’ muted color palette. One fan responded: “Looks awful.. I don’t understand why the lighting and food looks awful compared to the original films,” Another added: “It looks very cold. I like the organic warmth of the original’s grading.”
The complaints echo reactions to the first trailer, which HBO released in March as part of its 10-year plan to reboot the wizarding franchise. That preview drew similar criticism for what fans identified as low-contrast color grading common in modern productions. “This whole trailer feels less magical than like the entirety of the pre existing Harry Potter films, sorry to say but this is just weird lol,” a fan wrote at the time, noting the effect made the footage feel “fake.”
A third viewer posted about the new clip: “The colour is so diluted. The first Harry Potter movie’s dinner scene was bright and colourful,” Others shared side-by-side comparisons with the 2001 film, and some created their own edited versions with boosted contrast and saturation.
The visual criticism extended to the feast itself. “So dark when it should be warmly lit,” a fourth person responded on X. Another viewer wrote that Hogwarts was “supposed to feel magical, warm and lived-in,” continuing: “Even ordinary scenes like the Great Hall feasts had so much colour, texture and personality. Here, everything looks washed out, and the food doesn’t even look particularly appetising.”
Some fans joked that Hogwarts appeared to be suffering from “inflation,” posting comparisons between the abundant spreads in the original Warner Bros. Films and the more modest presentation in the HBO footage. “Hagrid looks like a businessman wearing a Hagrid cosplay and nothing looks good lol, it looks fake and lacking any colour,” one person said after the March trailer.

Not all reactions were negative. Several fans praised the casting and fidelity to J.K. Rowling’s source material. “When the food switched out to deserts just like the book said >>>,” one wrote. Another posted: “Easily my favourite part of this clip is the conversation between Dumbledore and McGonagall. Such a great example of how this show won’t be exclusively from Harry’s perspective and seeing them talk about how much Harry resembles James was a nice touch.”
HBO confirmed in March that the first season will use the original UK book title Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone rather than the Americanized Sorcerer’s Stone. The series is scheduled to premiere on Christmas Day.

