Glee co-creator says reboot will address cast deaths as some stars rule out returning

Ian Brennan, co-creator of Glee, has reversed his long-standing opposition to a reboot and confirmed the new series will directly address the deaths of cast members including Cory Monteith and Naya Rivera.

Brennan, who spent years dismissing revival talk, said he “completely did a 180 about” the project within recent months. He had previously wondered why anyone would want to re-do the musical phenomenon, but now believes “there’s something about that feels right right now.” Scripts are actively being developed, though Brennan cautioned, “We’re still figuring a lot of it out.”

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

“That’s going to be part of it, that sadness and that loss,” Brennan said of honoring the deceased cast. “But still in all, I think [Glee] is too big of a thing to sort of let lay.”

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

The reboot faces significant absences beyond those who have died. Chris Colfer, 35, who played Kurt Hummel across 116 episodes, ruled himself out back in 2019. Speaking to the outlet, Colfer invoked Dolly Parton to explain his position: “no amount of money can take from me the memories I have of then, but no amount of money can make me go back and do it all over again.” He called Glee “an incredible, life-changing experience” but made clear a return “wasn’t for him.”

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

Amber Riley, 38, who starred as Mercedes Jones, delivered an equally firm rejection on the Monét Talks podcast earlier this year. She said she wouldn’t appear even for massive financial offers.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

“I just feel like what we did was so phenomenal, I don’t want to risk trying to reinvent the wheel,” Riley explained. “We lost cast members. I just feel like the chemistry, that formula, was so specific, and it’s changed now, so I don’t know if it would be as effective.”

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

Lea Michele, 38, who played Rachel Berry, has publicly expressed interest in returning, though no formal casting announcements have been made.

The deaths that Brennan’s reboot will acknowledge began with Monteith, who was found dead in a Vancouver hotel room on July 13, 2013, from a heroin and alcohol overdose at age 31. The actor had struggled with substance abuse since adolescence and had recently completed rehab. Mark Salling, who played Puck, died by suicide on January 30, 2018, at 35 while awaiting sentencing on child pornography charges to which he had pleaded guilty.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

Rivera’s death on July 8, 2020, at age 33, came during a boating outing with her then-four-year-old son Josey on California’s Lake Piru. An incident report determined she drowned from exhaustion after heroically pushing the child back onto their drifting boat. Robin Trocki, who played Sue Sylvester’s sister Jean, died in December 2019 at 63 from Alzheimer’s complications.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

The list of deceased guest stars and recurring players extends considerably. Olivia Newton-John, who appeared as herself, died from breast cancer in August 2022 at 73. Meat Loaf, who played Barry Jeffries in season two, died in January 2022 at 74. Tim Conway, season five’s Marty Rogers, died in May 2019 at 85 from normal pressure hydrocephalus. Michael Lerner, who joined in season four as Sidney Greene, died in April 2023 at 81 from brain seizure complications.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

Further losses include Jean Sincere, the “Ancient Librarian,” who died in April 2013 at 93; Barbara Tarbuck, who played teacher Nancy Bletheim, who died December 2016 at 74 from Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease; Patty Duke, season four jeweller Jan, who died March 2016 at 69 from sepsis; James Lipton, playing himself, who died March 2020 at 90 from bladder cancer; and Sonya Eddy, the “Angry Mom,” who died December 2022 at 55 from post-surgical infection. Additional deceased cast members include Jane Galloway Heitz, Phyllis Applegate, Tonita Castro, Mike Hagerty, Roger Keller, Michael Mandell, Edmund Shaff, and Suzanne Krull.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

Brennan’s conversion from skeptic to advocate marks a dramatic shift for a franchise once considered permanently concluded. The original series ran from 2009 to 2015 on Fox, becoming a cultural phenomenon while generating multiple soundtrack albums and concert tours. Its blend of high school drama, musical performance, and social commentary attracted a devoted fanbase that has sustained interest nearly a decade after the finale.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

The so-called “Glee curse” — a term fans and media have applied to the show’s pattern of tragedies and controversies — has shadowed discussions of any revival. Beyond the deaths, Salling’s criminal case and various cast conflicts have complicated the series’ legacy. Brennan’s acknowledgment that loss will be woven into the narrative suggests the reboot intends to confront rather than evade this history.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

Whether the project can recapture the original’s alchemy without key performers remains the central question. Riley’s concern about irreproducible chemistry echoes broader skepticism from portions of the fan community. The involvement of surviving creators and whatever returning cast they secure will determine whether the revival achieves the cultural relevance Brennan believes remains possible.

Every Glee actor who has died or said they won’t return as co-creator confirms reboot will address deaths

Disney is reportedly moving forward with development, with Brennan actively scripting.

Share this story